Edible
Requires preparation
Set your location to see data for your region.

A peculiar sac fungus with an apothecium composed of a dark, irregularly saddle-shaped cap 3–6 cm wide and a light grey, strongly ribbed stem. The upper, fertile surface of the cap is black or dark grey, smooth to wrinkled, and its margin is attached at several points to the stem. The lower surface is sterile, smooth, and dark grey. The stem measures 4–15 cm in length and 1.5–3 cm in thickness, is whitish to ash grey, chambered and hollow inside, covered with deep longitudinal grooves and connecting sharp ribs. The flesh is whitish, thin, cartilaginous, and brittle, with a faint odor. It grows from summer to autumn on bare soil in deciduous forests, parks, and along forest roads. Raw, it causes stomach upsets.
Identification, habitat, and key differences.
Forager
Fruitbody structure
- Fruit body form
- Fruit body form: Cap, stipe.
- Fruitbody height
- Fruitbody height: 50–120 mm.
Cap
- Margin orientation
- in mature fruit bodies: Margin orientation: curved downwards.
- Attachment of margin to stem
- in mature fruit bodies: Attachment of margin to stem: attached at points.
- Cap diameter
- The cap measures 20–70 mm in diameter.
- Cap height
- Cap height: 20–45 mm.
Underside of the cap
- Hymenophore type
- Hymenophore type: smooth.
- Hymenophore colour
- Hymenophore colour: black.
Stem and base
- Stipe colour
- Stipe colour: whitish.
Stipe colour: grayish. - Stipe surface relief
- Stipe surface relief: Ribbed and with shallow pits.
- Stipe surface covering
- Stipe surface covering: glabrous.
- Stipe interior
- Stipe interior: Chambered.
Stipe interior: hollow. - Stipe length
- Stipe length: 30–150 mm.
- Stipe diameter
- Stipe diameter: 10–60 mm.
Flesh
- Flesh colour
- Flesh colour: whitish.
Flesh colour: grayish.
Where and when it grows
- Habitat
- Habitat: deciduous woodland.
Habitat: roadside. - Substrate
- Substrate: soil.
- Fruit body growth pattern
- Fruit body growth pattern: solitary.
Fruit body growth pattern: in groups. - Fruiting season
- Fruit bodies appear from March to November.
- Distribution area
- Distribution area: confirmed.
Edibility and culinary use
- Edibility
- Edible
- Required preparation
- Requires preparation
What it can be confused with
Helvella crispa
Key differences
The fluted black elfin saddle (Helvella lacunosa) differs in having a distinctly darker, ash-gray, gray-brown to almost blackish cap and a gray stipe.
The white saddle (Helvella crispa) differs in having a pale, whitish to cream cap and a downy lower surface of the apothecium with an inrolled, free margin.
FAQ
Is the fluted black elfin saddle an edible mushroom?
Opinions are divided: field guides such as grzyby.pl or ČMS (sensu lato) list it as edible, but other sources warn of the risk of gyromitrin presence and advise against consumption.
What does the cap of the fluted black elfin saddle look like?
The cap is saddle-shaped, folded, with irregular lobes ranging in color from ash grey, through dark brown, to black.
What characterizes its stem?
The stem is grey to blackish, characteristically ribbed, longitudinally grooved, and chambered and hollow in cross-section.
Where does the fluted black elfin saddle most commonly occur?
It grows on the ground in deciduous and coniferous forests, along forest paths, in parks, often on sandy or moist soils.
When does the fluted black elfin saddle fruit?
Fruit bodies grow mostly from summer to late autumn (from July to November), occasionally also in spring.
How does the fluted black elfin saddle differ from the white saddle?
It differs primarily in coloration: the fluted black elfin saddle has a grey to black cap and stem, while the white saddle is creamy white or pale yellow.
What are the symptoms of potential poisoning by this mushroom?
In case of toxin ingestion, nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain may occur, and in more severe gyromitrin poisonings, liver damage. Field guide assessments do not rule out such a risk.
What consistency does the flesh of the fluted black elfin saddle have?
The flesh is thin, brittle, elastic-waxy, greyish, without a distinct taste, and with a neutral odor.
Which taxonomic group does the fluted black elfin saddle belong to?
It belongs to the family Helvellaceae and the phylum Ascomycota, in which spores are formed inside asci.
What ecological function does the fluted black elfin saddle serve?
According to ČMS, it is a probably mycorrhizal species forming relationships with trees, although in the literature it is also sometimes classified as a saprotroph decomposing litter.
Enthusiast
Names and history
- Obowiązująca nazwa krajowa
- piestrzyca zatokowata
- Obowiązująca nazwa taksonomiczna
- Helvella lacunosa Afzel.
- Inne nazwy krajowe
- Elfin Saddle
Home observations
Spore print
- Required materials
- fresh, mature cap, sheet of paper, glass or small bowl, water
- Time
- 2–24 h
- Procedure
- Place the cap underside down on the paper.
- Add a drop of water on top and cover.
- After 2–24 hours, lift the cap and examine the deposit.
What to look for
- Spore print colour
- Spore print colour: white.
Under the microscope
- Required materials
- light microscope, microscope slide and cover slip, needle, water, spores from print
- Procedure
- Transfer a small amount of the spore print onto the slide using a needle.
- Add a drop of water, cover with a cover slip, and examine the spores.
What to look for
- Spore shape
- Spore shape: ellipsoid. Spore shape: ellipsoid.
- Spore surface
- Spore surface: smooth.
- Spore dimensions
- Length 10–20 µm, width 9–13 µm.
Compare dimensions after calibrating the microscope scale.
Non-culinary uses
Nowadays, the fluted black elfin saddle finds niche use in textile handicrafts and amateur wool dyeing (mushroom dyeing). Extracts from fruit bodies, depending on the metallic mordants used (e.g., potassium alum or iron sulfate), allow obtaining muted shades of beige, ash gray, and smoky olive browns on natural fibers. Due to the limited availability of raw material and the moderate durability of pigments, this is exclusively a hobbyist and workshop practice, without commercial significance.
A second contemporary area of use is nature education and museology. Preserved or dried fruit bodies serve as exhibits in mushroom exhibitions and as teaching aids in forestry education to present the morphological diversity of cup fungi.
In ethnomycological and historical sources, there is no evidence of former use of the fluted black elfin saddle in folk medicine, wound dressing, household craft, or ritual beliefs and rites. This species was not an object of interest in traditional herbalism, and in former culture, no tangible medicinal or raw-material properties were attributed to it.
History and culture
The history of research on the fluted black elfin saddle dates back to the 18th century, and the designation of an epitype in 2017 made it possible to precisely link the name to the genetic profile of European populations.
The former classification of the false morel in the genus Helvella was the source of many years of misunderstanding regarding the degree of toxicity of elfin saddles.
Historical sites documented in Polish landscape parks illustrate many years of floristic research on ascomycetes in the country.
Edibility and safety
In traditional field guides, the mushroom was sometimes considered edible after cooking, but modern literature advises against collecting it due to its low culinary value, an undetermined toxicological profile, and the risk of gastrointestinal poisoning.
Raw fruit bodies can cause gastrointestinal poisoning. The fluted black elfin saddle is sometimes confused with other dark elfin saddles.
In some people, consuming cooked white saddle (Helvella crispa) also caused nausea and dizziness. The described case involved a dish prepared in a pressure cooker.
Habitat and occurrence
The fluted black elfin saddle occurs in deciduous, coniferous, and mixed forests, as well as in city parks, thickets, and along the edges of forest roads. It appears on moist, sandy, humic, and calcareous soils, often among fallen leaves or in moss. This species is also encountered on old fire sites and campfire spots. It forms mycorrhizal relationships with deciduous and coniferous trees, most commonly with oaks, beeches, pines, and spruces.
The geographic range covers the temperate zone of the Northern Hemisphere, including almost all of Europe. In Poland, it is a native species, widely distributed on the lowlands and in the upland belt and submontane regions, although at individual sites it usually grows in a dispersed manner.
Although the main fruiting season in Central Europe falls in the period from late summer to late autumn (usually from August to November, with the greatest intensity in September and October), in a broad sense (sensu lato) individual fruit bodies are found as early as late spring, from May and June. In cooler climates, the season is closed by early November frosts, whereas in warmer regions of Southern Europe and the Mediterranean basin, the phenology of the species shifts—fruit bodies can be found there also in the winter months, until early spring.
Researcher
Edibility and culinary use
Ustalenia źródłowe: jadalność, spożycie i wykorzystanie
- Edibility
- Edible
Źródło bez opisu bibliograficznego · jadalne czy trujące? — Jadalna.
Źródło oznaczenia.
Źródło bez opisu bibliograficznego · jadalne czy trujące? — Jadalna.
- Required processing
- Requires preparation
Źródło bez opisu bibliograficznego · druk144: H. lacunosa; druk145/PDF145: In conclusione ... dopo completa cottura ... La prebollitura ... facoltativa.
Scientific names and taxonomy
- Current scientific name
Helvella lacunosa Afzel.
- Former scientific names
- Costapeda lacunosa (Afzel.) Falck
Helvella nigricans Schaeff.[13]
- Zakres ujęcia taksonomicznego
Helvella lacunosa Afzel., current IF147441 and narrow European Skrede2017/2020 concept, epitype H407. Independent Polish atlas observations retain their source identifications, without a new molecular reidentification. Czech explicitly sensu-lato group, WestAmerican complex, folk taxa, historical misapplications and specimen H059 phenotype are not merged into one material or an unqualified narrow species result.
[9] [13] [1]
Laboratory diagnostics
Dane ustrukturyzowane
Asci
Remaining laboratory characters
Spores
- Spore surface
- Spore surface: smooth. [8]
Material and research methods
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Narrow Skrede2017 H.lacunosa, epitypeH407; independent named Polish atlas reports are not freshly reidentified. Exact source src-skrede-2017-current-20261006", {}, null, null]
Wygięcie wstawki; Przegrody wstawki — zapis źródłowy: „Parafizy proste, septowane, z maczugowatymi wierzchołkami; prawie bezbarwne do jasnobrązowych niżej, bardziej brązowe ku górze.” [13]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Skrede2017 narrow paraphyses, distinct shaft/apex, sample number unknown", {}, null, null]
Szerokość wstawki — zapis źródłowy: „Szerokość parafiz niżej 3–4 µm; maczugowate wierzchołki 6–8 µm.” [13]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Narrow European primary material", {}, null, null]
Długość zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Długość 17–19 µm; pełna para wymiarów zarodnika 17–19 × 9–11,5 µm, H. lacunosa sensu stricto, rewizja 2017.” [13]
Szerokość zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Szerokość 9–11,5 µm; pełna para wymiarów zarodnika 17–19 × 9–11,5 µm, H. lacunosa sensu stricto, rewizja 2017.” [13]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Polish atlas source-identified H.lacunosa, not new DNA identification; exact published axis", {}, null, null]
Długość zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Polski atlas: pełna para 10–20 × 10–13 µm; czeski sensu lato: 15–20 × 9–12 µm. Długość jest pierwszą osią każdej odrębnej pary; metody atlasów niepodane.” [8]
Szerokość zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Polski atlas: pełna para 10–20 × 10–13 µm; czeski sensu lato: 15–20 × 9–12 µm. Szerokość jest drugą osią każdej odrębnej pary; metody atlasów niepodane.” [8]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Source-specific ascospore shape src-skrede-2017-current-20261006", {}, null, null]
Kształt zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Wąskoelipsoidalne w europejskiej rewizji.” [13]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Source-specific ascospore shape src-grzyby-current-20261006", {}, null, null]
Kształt zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Polski atlas: krótkoelipsoidalne; czeski sensu lato: owalne. Metody preparatów niepodane.” [8]
Metody i zapisy źródłowe — Exact source material and scope: ["Narrow Skrede2017 H.lacunosa, epitypeH407; independent named Polish atlas reports are not freshly reidentified. Exact source src-grzyby-current-20261006", {}, null, null]
Powierzchnia zarodnika — zapis źródłowy: „Zarodniki gładkie w atlasach polskim i czeskim sensu lato; nie podano metody preparatu.” [8]
Occurrence verification — scope and limitations
Materiał: Polska lista gatunków i wskazany wpis atlasowy, z zachowaniem pojęcia nazwy autora.
Zakres odczytu: Fragmenty źródeł.
Odczytano fragment źródła; pełny tekst i metody nie zostały zweryfikowane.
Data przeglądu: 09.11.2026.
Ograniczenia: Odczytano atlas i jego informację o czekliście; nie zadeklarowano niezależnego odczytu całej czeklisty Chmiel 2006 ani badań molekularnych.
[4]Materiał: Published collections of the named Helvella in Grzędy protective unit, Biebrza National Park, August 2012.
Zakres odczytu: Pełny tekst.
Data przeglądu: 09.11.2026.
Ograniczenia: Names and identifications remain those of the 2012 authors; no modern molecular reidentification of these vouchers is asserted. The study reports morphological/microscopic identification generally. Molecular identification is not assigned to either focal Helvella record. Individual collection dates are not converted into the complete fruiting season. The official geographic reference establishes location only, not fungal occurrence or legal collection permission.
[5] [6]Scope of the review
Required checks are settled.
Key substances and their effects
Habitat and occurrence
Potwierdzony zasięg występowania
Wszystkie obszary potwierdzone w zapisanych danych źródłowych.
| Kraj | Regiony i stanowiska | Fruiting | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poland | Podlaskie Voivodeship | III–XI |
|
Sources
- W2-LACUNOSA-VERIFICATION
- Gierczyk/Rejowski, Helvella lacunosa (także [8])
- Kujawa et al. 2012, Preliminary studies of fungi in the Biebrza National Park (NE Poland). II. Macromycetes, Acta Mycologica 47(2): 235–264
- review20261109.grzedy-geography
- Chmiel2019AnnotatedCatalogueRoztocze
- IndexFungorum147441
- ČMS, KarelTejkal, Helvella lacunosa
- Nguyen, Landeros, Garibay-Orijel, Hansen, Vellinga 2013;Mycologia105:1275–1286
- RegionePiemonte 2021, guida commestibilità
- Skrede, Carlsen, Schumacher 2017;Persoonia39:201–253
- Skrede, BallesterGonzalvo, Mathiesen, Schumacher 2020;FSE6:65–93